Creating a Cost-Conscious & Realistic Target College List
Let’s create your Target College List!
Hey there, high schoolers and parents! Thinking about college can be as exciting as it is daunting. The good news is, you don’t have to navigate this journey alone. In this article, we’ll guide you through creating a target college list that’s both cost-conscious and realistic for admissions, without making the process feel like a Herculean task. So, let’s dive in!

By the way, Going Merry’s College Match Tool helps you compare colleges to help you build your target college list. Check out the tool today to start comparing colleges!
Understanding College Costs: Billed and Non-Billed Expenses
First things first: let’s break down the costs associated with college. Understanding the full picture will help you make informed decisions.
- Tuition and Fees: These are the direct costs billed by the college. They cover your classes and access to campus facilities and services.
- Housing and Meals: If you plan to live on campus, you’ll have costs for a dorm room and meal plans. Living off-campus? You’ll need to budget for rent and groceries.
- Books and Supplies: Textbooks can be surprisingly expensive, not to mention other supplies like notebooks, software, and lab materials.
- Transportation: Whether you’re commuting or occasionally heading home for the holidays, factor in costs for public transportation, gas, parking, or flights.
- Personal Expenses: These are the day-to-day costs like laundry, entertainment, and personal care items.
It’s essential to consider these expenses as they can add up quickly. Knowing the full scope of costs will help you stay financially prepared.
Merit-Based Scholarships: What Are Your Chances?
Merit-based scholarships are awarded based on academic performance, talents, or other achievements. Research the typical profile of students who receive merit scholarships at each school on your list. Are your grades, test scores, and extracurriculars in line with these profiles? This can give you an idea of the merit aid you might expect.
Need-Based Financial Aid: Federal, State, and Institutional Help
You should also estimate what kind of need-based aid you might receive. This includes federal grants, state aid, and institutional scholarships. The Department of Education has a Net Price Calculator on its website where you can get an estimate of your expected financial aid package at different schools based on your family’s financial information.
Sign up for a Going Merry account to access the Going Merry College Match Tool, which helps you compare colleges based on things like average cost, admission rates, academics, student life, and more!
The Big Picture: Combining Costs and Aid
When it comes to choosing a college, understanding the full financial picture is crucial. This goes beyond just looking at tuition fees. To get a clearer idea of the total cost, you need to factor in additional expenses like room and board, textbooks, transportation, and personal costs. Once you’ve compiled a comprehensive list of these expected costs for each college you’re considering, you can start to assess how much aid you might receive. This includes financial aid packages from the school, federal and state grants, scholarships, work-study opportunities, and loans.
By taking the time to fully evaluate both the costs and the potential financial aid you may receive, you’ll be able to estimate the true cost—how much you’ll actually need to pay out of pocket. This is often referred to as your “net cost,” and it’s a number that is crucial when comparing schools. Some colleges may offer generous aid that significantly reduces your out-of-pocket expenses, while others might have a higher sticker price but offer less aid.
A key strategy in ensuring you have more options is to apply to a variety of schools with different price points. Think about including:
- Reach schools: These are schools that may be a financial stretch but offer substantial financial aid or have a scholarship that could make the price more manageable.
- Safety schools: More affordable options where you’re more likely to receive substantial financial aid or merit-based scholarships, making the overall cost more reasonable.
- Target schools: Schools that fall somewhere in between, where your chances of receiving a reasonable financial aid offer are strong.
By applying to a diverse group of schools, you give yourself the flexibility to make an informed decision based on your financial aid offers. Once you receive those offers, you can evaluate each school’s net cost, including any differences in what’s covered by grants and what you’ll need to borrow. You can also weigh factors like location (which might affect travel costs or summer work opportunities) or whether living at home for a year might help save money.
In the end, you’re not just choosing the school that looks the best on paper; you’re choosing the one that aligns with your academic and personal goals and fits within your financial reality. Having more choices at this stage will ultimately help you make a decision that sets you up for both success and financial well-being in the long run.

Seeking Professional Help
If this feels overwhelming, know that you’re not alone. There are professionals who specialize in helping families navigate the college financial aid process. They can provide personalized advice and strategies for maximizing aid and minimizing debt, ensuring you’re making the most of available resources. These specialists can also help you understand the intricacies of financial aid forms, such as the Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA®) and College Scholarship Service (CSS Profile), and guide you through the appeal process if the initial offer doesn’t meet your needs. With their expertise, you can approach the financial aid process with confidence, knowing you have a trusted partner by your side.
Applying to Multiple Schools
A smart and strategic way to approach the college application process is to apply to a range of schools that you’re interested in and then wait for the financial aid award letters to roll in. While it may feel like a lot of effort upfront, this approach is one of the best ways to ensure you’re making a well-informed decision. By applying to multiple schools, you’ll be able to compare not only the academic programs and campus environments but also the financial aid offers you receive.
Each school’s financial aid package may differ significantly, and it’s essential to assess these offers in depth. Consider factors like the amount of grants and scholarships versus loans, as well as work-study opportunities. While a school may seem affordable at first glance, its financial aid package might offer more—or less—help than expected, impacting your out-of-pocket costs.
Once the financial aid award letters arrive, you can make a direct comparison. Be sure to factor in both the academic value and the financial considerations. For instance, one school might offer you a generous scholarship that significantly lowers the cost, while another may have a higher sticker price but offer a stronger program in your field of interest. Don’t forget to consider other financial aspects, like the cost of living in the area, travel expenses, and potential for part-time work during the school year.
This method also gives you a safety net: if one or two schools don’t offer enough financial aid, you have alternatives to fall back on. It’s important to weigh all aspects, from academic opportunities to the total cost, and select the best fit for both your educational goals and financial reality. This way, you’re setting yourself up for success in more ways than one. While it might seem like a time-consuming process at first, the end result is worth it—it ensures you’re armed with the information you need to make a decision that fits your academic aspirations and your budget.
Wrapping Up
Creating a cost-conscious and realistic target college list doesn’t have to be stressful. By understanding all the potential costs, exploring financial aid options, and being open to professional guidance, you can make informed decisions that pave the way for a bright and affordable college future.
Remember, the journey to college is as much about finding the right financial fit as it is about finding the right academic and social environment. Happy college hunting, and best of luck!
Disclaimer: This blog post provides personal finance educational information, and it is not intended to provide legal, financial, or tax advice.
- Creating a Cost-Conscious & Realistic Target College List - February 27, 2025
- State Grants and Scholarships for New York Residents in 2025 - February 13, 2025
- What Happens at a College Financial Aid Night (And Why You Should Go) - January 7, 2025